Thematic Review of Risk Management Maturity – Summary of Key Findings

Thematic Review of Risk Management Maturity – Summary of Key Findings

Earlier this year, the Central Bank of Ireland (CBI) conducted a Thematic Review of Risk Management Maturity in Credit Unions. While the CBI acknowledges the progress that credit unions have made in terms of risk management maturity, it has highlighted some key areas for improvement. Below, we’ve briefly summarised these findings.

“Good governance and robust risk management are necessary and critical business enablers for credit unions in protecting members’ funds, addressing current challenges and leveraging available opportunities”

Patrick Casey, Registrar of Credit Unions, 2021

Board Ownership and Oversight

  • Little evidence of ownership of risk management by the Board (communicating actions, decisions, and feedback on reports).
  • Little evidence in many cases of robust discussion taking place at Board meetings on risk-related issues.
  • Little evidence of engagement between the Board and the RMO on decisions taken to mitigate risks.
  • Limited face-to-face interaction between the Board and the RMO (infrequent attendance at Board meetings).
  • Large dependency on a small number of Board members to address the issues raised by the RMO relating to risk.
  • Over reliance on sub-committees (e.g. Audit & Risk Committee)
  • Lack of evidence of regular reviews of the risk management framework (by the BoD)
  • Lack of evidence of involvement of the RMO in the development and maintenance of the strategic plan

 

Risk Management Function – Structure and Framework

  • Disconnect between 1LoD and 2LoD – little or no engagement between the front-line staff and the RMO.
  • Risk-related work done by 2LoD in a ‘silo’ – typically RMO, CEO and the management team.
  • No formal process for front-line staff (first line of defence) to report existing or potential risks.
  • Issues with independence of the RMF – RMO not reporting directly to the Board on a regular basis.
  • CEO requesting substantive changes to reports before being submitted to sub-committees / Board.
  • RMO being involved in ‘operational’ / first line of defence work.
  • Inconsistencies in the application of policies, procedures and other documentation relating to risk management.
  • Issues with the practically of risk registers – too many risks, duplication and not reflecting the risk profile of the credit union.

 

Risk Management Reporting

  • Fewer risk reports submitted than expected as per the credit union’s own policy
  • Work to do regarding the quality of risk reporting – lacking in detail, not tailored sufficiently for the CU and not discussing areas that have been previously flagged in regulatory engagements.

 

Training & Culture

  • Lack of evidence of training being planned for.
  • No evidence of training being provided in relation to the CU’s own risk management framework.
  • Lack of clarity around how policy updates are communicated to all in the credit union

 

Click here for more information on how the CalQRisk solution can help your credit union with its risk management obligations.

Recent News

forward thinking imagery

Incident vs Crisis

Not every incident/event is a crisis, but it can have the potential to become a crisis if not ...
Read More
Logging in to attend a CalQRisk webinar

Operational Resilience vs Business Continuity 

At first glance, you might think Operational Resilience is just Business Continuity (BC) by another name, but there ...
Read More
Central bank of ireland building

Assessing your Outsourcing Governance Framework

In March 2022, the Central Bank of Ireland fined BNY Mellon Fund Services €10.78 million for 16 regulatory ...
Read More
laptops on a table doing risk reports

Cybersecurity – What are the risks?

With changes to working culture, and more people working from home than ever, businesses can see the importance ...
Read More
IWD2022 employee spotlight

International Women’s Day Spotlight – Fiona Kiely

It's International Women's Day and today we would like to shine the spotlight on our very own Fiona ...
Read More
risk assessment

10 Key Steps to getting Operational Resilience off the ground

It can seem daunting to begin a brand-new process for your business. However, risk assessments are an easy ...
Read More
CalQRisk and CUMA

CalQRisk at CUMA Spring Conference

CalQRisk will be attending the CUMA Spring Conference & AGM 2022 – “Changing Landscapes” The conference takes place ...
Read More
regtech 100 2022 badge

CalQRisk included in the RegTech 100 List

Now in its fifth edition, the list recognises the world’s most innovative technology solution providers that offer products ...
Read More
risk management cogs and gears of plan

Thematic Review of Risk Management Maturity – Summary of Key Findings

Thematic Review of Risk Management Maturity – Summary of Key Findings Earlier this year, the Central Bank of ...
Read More
Sunday Business Post Logo

Business Post – Improving the Odds

We were delighted to be featured in the Business Post recently. In the article, our CTO discussed the ...
Read More